Skip to main content

The story of the other Kashmir

While parts of Indian Kashmir is on the boil again, with national media focused on giving us an unbiased view, I paused to understand how different life was on the other side of the border, in what is euphemistically called “Azad” Jammu & Kashmir – an Azad J&K that some Kashmiris on the Indian side desire to be part of, through what Pakistan terms as a ‘UN plebiscite’. By the way, I learnt that the plebiscite, that has since been superseded by the post-war 1972 Gandhi-Bhutto Simla Accord which requires India and Pakistan to resolve the Kashmir issue peacefully and bilaterally, states unequivocally that Pakistan must completely demilitarize its side of the border, which obviously, it cannot, and will not let happen in the foreseeable future.

Back anyway to what I gleaned about Azad Kashmir. Azad Kashmir is lead by the President of Azad J&K, who takes oath of office, swearing that his office is lower to the country and to the cause of accession to the State of Pakistan. Wow! Some azadi this!
And in order to run for office in AJ&K, every candidate has to provide a written declaration that AJ&K will be an integral part of Pakistan. The first AJ&K election happened in 1970, a full twenty-three years after the new nation of Pakistan declared Kashmir to be an independent country, with its right to self-determination. During those interim twenty-three years, a team ‘selected’ by Rawalpindi ran the AJ&K administration. Some azadi this!
And since candidates require signing the pledge of allegiance, local parties that want true independence, from both Pakistan & India, never participate in these elections. So it is back to members of the same old Pakistan Peoples Party, and Pakistan Union Muslim League, that run & get elected in AJ&K. Some azadi, this.
In 1963, when there was no elected government in place, Pakistan quietly ceded a part of AJ&K, called the Shaksgam tract to China! And it is now part of the Uyghur autonomous region of China. Azadi to sell some else’s property, without their permission? Man, oh man.
AJ&K is actually controlled by the AJ&K Council, made up of the Prime Minister of Pakistan, the President and Prime Minister of AJ&K (PPP members currently), and five AJ&K legislative assembly members (guess which parties they belong to?). If these were not enough, the administrative team is comprised of a Chief Secretary, Finance Secretary, Accountant General, and IG Police, all appointed by Islamabad, who sit in Islamabad, and are necessarily, hold your breath, non-Kashmiris. Really? This is azadi?
AJ&K, for all its azadi, neither has the power to issue its own currency, raise its own army, collect its own taxes, issue its own passport, or have UN representation. Azadi to do what, then?
What kind of azadi is this? And what kind of an ‘azad’ state do these secessionists in the Indian part of J&K want to belong to? Surely, they can aspire for a better system, cant they? 
Now, do we in India - media, administration, political parties, and the common man, make an effort to explain patiently, this reality to these growing number of misguided youths on our side of Kashmir? Or do we see it as a waste of time and effort, and only see a military end to this problem?
PS: Azadi=freedom 

Comments

Rama said…
Your writing has so much clarity that even an ignoramus will understand very well what you mean.
How do we explain to them about the reality of their Azadi is the most important question..
Thank you once again Naresh for a brilliant post.
Rama said…
Your writing has so much clarity that even an ignoramus will understand very well what you mean.
How do we explain to them about the reality of their Azadi is the most important question..
Thank you once again Naresh for a brilliant post.

Popular posts from this blog

Will The Nation State of Pakistan Survive?

I know, I know…. I am not a political junkie, and some of my friends and acquaintances know a lot more about the geopolitics of South Asia than I can ever aspire to know, but let me just take a stab at this subject, to partially quench my intellectual curiosity. Of course blogs and social media are hardly the medium for such conversations; it has the tendency to provide a platform where animated discussions can quickly degenerate into a slugfest. But let me still take the plunge. The title is of course eyeball grabbing, quite unintentionally though. That is however the nub of my story, if at all you may call this a story. So let me get to the point right away. If Pakistan continues its current trajectory, it may not last - not a few decades, not a few years, but not even two years. Yes, Pakistan as we know I suspect will cease to exist as a nation, for not a day more than 75 years since its birth, if trends were to be believed. And its demise may have nothing to do with a nuclear...

The King is Dead. Long Live The King.

1984. I was in Kolkata on a business trip. I was watching life go by through the large bay windows at our office, sipping hot chai, when I noticed a flurry of activity. Shops pulled their shutters down rapidly, swarms of buses pulled across to block streets and white cars with flags wove dangerously through a melee of people scurrying away. I soon learnt why. Indira Gandhi had been shot. We closed business and wound our way back home. I innocently agreed to walk a frightened sardarji to a safe house couple of miles away. Having safely deposited him in his gurudwara, I ducked, hid and ran the eleven miles back to the guest house I was staying in as I watched, without comprehension, mobs with hate-filled eyes go after people that till then were woven into the fabric of the city. That day, I saw hate and anger like never before, and read more about it the next day. A small part of me died that day.   Many years later, I was visiting my city, Mumbai for an extended stay. Singapore had...

The making of a new India?

I recently read an Economist article headlined “India’s prime minister is not as much of a reformer as he seems”. Coming from a reputed international newsmagazine, it was a bit surprising that such an impactful headline, was not followed up with depth or detail to make the point stick. From an economic standpoint, almost every ill - near bankruptcy of large PSU banks, poor tax compliance, massive bureaucracy in state sales tax (to a point that almost every state collected just about enough sales tax to pay the wages of the taxmen - yes, does it not surprise you?) that delivered zero meaningful revenue to the state, are a throwback of the past. Whether it was due to 63 years of Congress rule, 2 years of Janata Party rule, or 5 years of the previous BJP rule is not relevant; this, and every previous government inherited a plethora of problems that were/are extremely tough to untangle. It is a fact that every government of the past, especially the one with Janardhan Poojary as a min...